Eating + Drinking

5 Ways to Indulge Your Oyster Obsession

Lemon. Slurp. Smile. Repeat.

Photo courtesy of Doug Lyle Thompson

We’re suckers—or, dare I say, shuckers?—for a good oyster. While fantastic oyster happy hours are aplenty throughout NYC, there’s so much more here for mollusk lovers. Grab the horseradish, because we’ve got five truly special experiences for oyster aficionados.

1. Tour (and restore) their habitats.
New York City waterways get a bad rep—recent tall tales about three-eyed catfish in the Gowanus Canal don’t help matters—but certain initiatives are looking to rehabilitate the urban oyster’s natural habitat. Turnstile Tours offers a monthly guided exploration of Kings County’s unique ecology around the Brooklyn Navy Yard, with one stop being an oyster restoration project on the banks of the East River helmed by the Billion Oyster Project. The program, organized by the New York Harbor Foundation, aims to reverse the effects of overharvesting by introducing oysters and their aquaculture back to NYC’s maritime environment. Students from New York Harbor School—the only school based on Governors Island—are in charge of building and operating nurseries and raising oysters throughout their life cycles.

best oysters nyc
Photo courtesy of Turnstile Tours

2. Journey to New England, by way of the Bronx.
Take advantage of those coveted Summer Friday hours or take a personal day, because an excursion to the quiet fishing village of City Island is an all-day affair, offering antiques shops, nautical museums, quirky gallery spaces, and The Royal Tenenbaums summertime haunt to explore. The best part: the seafood. We recommend heading to Johnny’s Reef for a basket of fried oysters, with a harborside view and a refreshing sea breeze.

best oysters nyc
Photo courtesy of Doug Lyle Thompson

3. Slurp them on a boat with the Hudson River breeze in your hair.
Inspired by the oyster barges floating down the East and Hudson rivers in the 19th century, Grand Banks runs one of the city’s best oyster bars on a gorgeous and historic wooden schooner. In addition to the oysters, enjoy wild-caught and sustainably harvested fish dishes, a bottle of rosé—and the sunset over Manhattan. A portion of Grand Banks’s profits go to the Maritime Foundation, a nonprofit whose mission is preserving NYC’s maritime culture and educating the public about the city’s rich marine history. Some of the industry’s leading experts in seafood sustainability and nautical preservation often host lectures on board, as well.

best oysters nyc
Photo courtesy of Alan Silverman

4. Go shuck yourself.
We’ve seen enough home-shucking horror stories on YouTube to give us nightmares for years, but instructors Kimberly Severson and Crystal Cun are armed and ready to guide you through the debearding process so that your oysters (and your fingers) remain intact. Head to Astor Center for their hands-on oyster shucking and tasting class. You’ll never be as swift as the pros, but at least you’ll know how to pry your way to sea-salted bliss the next time you have a craving. Don’t worry, you get to eat the oysters you open (motivation!) and taste the slight nuances that differentiate half shells from one another. Bonus: Wine from downstairs neighbor Astor Wine + Spirits will be on hand to round out the experience.

best oysters nyc
Photo courtesy of Alexander Pincus

5. Visit the oyster mecca.
If you’re 
searching for a grandiose oyster happy-hour spot, you might as well head to the mother of all pearls: Grand Central Oyster Bar. Since opening its doors more than a century ago, the iconic space shucks an average of five million oysters per year. While the saloon’s postwork specials are pretty mouthwatering (roasted oysters served with anchovy butter is the briny dish of my dreams), it’s hard not to take a chance on its mile-long oyster list. It’s a little ambitious to eat your way through the hefty menu in one go, but you have plenty of time to try them all since the rumor revolving around eating oysters in months that don’t end in ‘r’ is just that.

best oysters nyc
Photo courtesy of Carolina Ramirez

Let us know if you’re ready for a briny good time around the city.